Battle Royale [Audiobook Review]

TitleBattle Royale
Author: Koushun Takami
Narrator: Mark Dacascos
Genre: Thriller
Pages: 617
Audio: 19.5 hours
Year: 1999
Publisher: Simon Audio
Source: Review copy provided by publisher
Book Rating: 3/5
Audio Rating: 2.5/5

Summary:

Under the guise of aiding the country’s military, 42 Japanese classmates are brought to an island, where they are instructed to kill each other until only one remains. But Shuya Nanahara doesn’t want to play the game. After witnessing his best friend’s murder, he teams up with Noriko Nakagawa to find an escape.

My Thoughts:

My husband just asked me if I enjoyed this book. I’m not sure you can “enjoy” Battle Royale, but I was intrigued and very curious to see how it was going to end since Shuya and the others seemed to be in a hopeless scenario. The translation is rough, but the fast-moving plot helps push through any awkwardness.

While Shuya is the focus, the book switches point of view frequently to tell the stories of the other stories. I heard the CW might be making this into a television show, and I think it could work really well if each secondary character got an episode to tell their story before they die. I would watch that show.

I’ve wanted to read Battle Royale since hearing that The Hunger Games was very similar. I preferred The Hunger Games. Battle Royale is REALLY violent. I know it is kids killing kids and it’s awful no matter what, but in one scene a girl gouges a boy’s eyes out in excruciating detail. I just want to make sure you have that heads up. I also thought the world-building in The Hunger Games was much better. Here, I was confused why they were fighting and why they were making modern day references if it was some time in the future (or maybe it wasn’t).

One problem I had is that there are 42 Japanese names to keep track of and to my American year, many of them sounded very similar (a Yukie, Yuko, and Yuka all in the same scene?!) and were difficult to keep straight.

I’m still thinking about Battle Royale although I finished it over a week ago. It’s not a book I am going to forget anytime soon.

Audiobook Thoughts:

As I said above, the translation was rough, and the emotionally detached narrator did not help smooth it out. Dacascos performance lacked any character differentiation which could have given the reader a way to keep all of the students straight. I am curious if the flat narration was a conscious choice given the book’s culture. The narration wasn’t bad – it just wasn’t what it could have been. That said, I’m glad I listened to this. I may have been tempted to put it down in print when the violence surged.

3 thoughts on “Battle Royale [Audiobook Review]

  1. Bob September 27, 2012 / 11:18 am

    If I remember correctly, Battle Royale is supposed to be Alternate History, so it took place roughly in the present, just with an different historical landscape. The book doesn’t really spell that out very well though. I agree with you on the world building. I think the Hunger Games used the games to set up her dystopian world, while Battle Royale used its dystopian world to set up The Program, if that makes any sense.

    I wondered about the cultural elements as well with the narration. As this is Dacasco’s first narration, I tend to think he was just probably ill prepared, or simply decided his role was to read the book.

    Like

  2. zibilee September 27, 2012 / 11:45 am

    I have heard a lot about this book, but have sort of shied away from it for some reason. Perhaps it is because I was a big lover of The Hunger Games, and I didn’t want a repeat, but you make it sound as if this book is worthwhile on its own merits. Very nice review today. I might go for this one in print.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s